You are the read on the business, not just the record of it.
This is the first corporate hire, because nothing else works until the numbers work. You start as a team of one with an outsourced bookkeeping firm behind you and build the finance function from there.
If you'll do it once, you do it by hand. If twice, you automate it.
This is the path to CFO. You build the function as the platform grows, from an outsourced bookkeeping relationship you manage to your own team as the club count climbs, and grow into the senior finance seat rather than having one hired over you.
Attributes over experience. If you don't match every line, apply anyway.